What If You're Asking The Wrong Question?

What If You're Asking The Wrong Question?

There's a question you've been trying to answer.

Maybe for weeks.
Maybe for months.
Maybe for years.

You've thought about it. Read about it. Talked it through with people whose opinion you trust.

And you still don't have an answer that settles you.

Here's a possibility worth sitting with.

The answer isn't missing.
The question is wrong.

Because a badly framed question will absorb an unlimited amount of wrong answers and never be resolved. Not because you aren't looking hard enough... but because there was never a correct answer waiting at the end of it.

Take the most common one.

"What's wrong with me?"

Look at what that question is actually doing.

It assumes the conclusion before you start. It presupposes something is broken, then sends you off to find the evidence to prove the question right. And you will find it. You'll find it every single time, because that's what the question was built to do.

So you end up with a longer and longer list of things that are wrong with you, and you call that progress.

It isn't. It's just a question doing exactly what it's designed to do.

I've been down this path myself.

When I started doing serious psychological work, I went in with that exact question. And once you let that genie out of the bottle, there is no putting it back in.

I'd always thought my upbringing was straightforward. Loving parents, still rock solid after forty years. Big, caring extended family. We didn't have much early on, but we never went without.

Then you start looking properly, and you find things you'd never questioned because they were simply normal to you.

Arrangements you'd never examined. Second and third-order effects you'd never connected to anything.

And the more I looked, the more I found. Which felt like insight at the time.

But I was just answering the question I'd asked.

Now change the question and watch what happens.

"What makes me unique?"
"What one-of-a-kind experience do I have?"
"What is actually working that I should be doing more of?"

Same situation. Same facts. Same person.

Completely different answers.

Nothing changed except the question you asked.

And this shows up everywhere once you start noticing it.

In business, "why isn't this working?" keeps you circling the failure.
"What would have to be true for this to work?" points you at the next move.

In health, "why can't I stick to anything?" hands you a list of every time you've quit.
"What conditions have I actually succeeded under before?" hands you a blueprint.

In your career, "why am I so far behind?" measures you against other people.
"What am I building that doesn't show up yet?" measures you against where you're going.

One version of each of those keeps you stuck. The other moves you.

And they cost exactly the same amount of effort to ask.

So here's the giveaway...

If you've been asking the same question for a long time and still haven't landed on an answer that gives you any peace, stop hunting for a better answer.

Ask a better question.

If you know someone who would benefit from reading this, please forward it to them. It may change the trajectory of their life for the better, and the catalyst could be you.


Leave a comment

×